Thanksgiving in New York City: A Gourmet's Guide to Exceptional Dining in 2024
As the crisp autumn air settles over Manhattan and the city's iconic skyline glows under the golden hues of fall, New York City prepares for another unforgettable Thanksgiving. For those who prefer to leave the cooking to the experts, the city's culinary scene offers a cornucopia of options that cater to every palate. From classic American feasts to international twists on tradition, we've curated a selection of exceptional restaurants where you can celebrate Thanksgiving in style.
Casa Cruz New York
Address: 36 East 61st Street (between Park & Madison Ave.)
Occupying a six-story Beaux-Arts townhouse on the Upper East Side, Casa Cruz New York is an opulent haven where art and gastronomy converge. With interiors adorned by original works from Keith Haring, Andy Warhol, and William Turnbull, and silk panels designed by Joanna Ortiz, the restaurant offers an ambiance that's both luxurious and intimate.
Thanksgiving Offering: A three-course prix fixe menu at $140 per person, served from 1 PM to 10 PM on Thanksgiving Day. The culinary journey begins with honey-glazed cornbread and whipped cranberry ricotta. Starters include wild mushroom ravioli and other seasonal delights. Entrées range from braised stuffed turkey roulade with glazed chestnuts to maple cider-glazed salmon. Vegetarian options like a roasted pumpkin stuffed with fontina and oyster mushrooms are also available. Desserts feature rich pumpkin cream pie and a decadent banana Rhum Clément V.S.O.P. soufflé.
Reservations: Email reservations@casacruznyc.com or call (212) 970-8983. Reservations can also be made via Resy.
Le Rivage
Address: 340 West 46th Street
A staple in Manhattan's Theater District, Le Rivage has been delighting diners for 40 years with its classic French bistro fare. This year, the restaurant welcomes Chef de Cuisine David Cámara, a veteran of Vin Sur Vingt wine bar, who joins founding Chef Paul Denamiel in the kitchen.
Thanksgiving Offering: A three-course prix fixe menu priced at $85 per person. Specials include Butternut Squash Soup, Roasted Turkey Ballotine, and a selection of pies—warm apple, pumpkin, and poached pear. With its cozy ambiance and rich history, Le Rivage offers a traditional yet sophisticated Thanksgiving experience.
Reservations: Call (212) 765-7374 or visit Le Rivage's Website to reserve your table.
Nerai
Address: 55 East 54th Street
Nestled in Midtown East, Nerai infuses Greek hospitality into the Thanksgiving tradition. The elegant setting, combined with exquisite culinary offerings, makes it an ideal spot for a memorable holiday meal.
Thanksgiving Offering: A four-course prix fixe menu at $95 per person (and $45 for children), available from 3 PM to 9 PM. The feast begins with Spanakopita gougères, followed by starters like Winter Greek Salad and Grilled Octopus. Mid-course options include Lobster Pasta with poached Maine lobster and Sweet Potato Risotto. Entrées feature Turkey Moussaka & Roasted Turkey with cranberry sauce, Lavraki, and Baby Lamb Chops. Desserts include Pumpkin Cheesecake and Sokolatina. A selection of sides is available à la carte.
Reservations: Book via Resy or call (212) 759-5554.
Lindens
Address: 2 Renwick Street (inside the Arlo Soho)
Lindens offers a modern American dining experience in the heart of SoHo, focusing on seasonal ingredients and innovative dishes.
Thanksgiving Offering: A prix fixe menu at $85 per person. The meal starts with Parker House Rolls and appetizers like Honeycrisp Apples & Endive and Baked Figs & Brie. The main course features a perfectly roasted turkey breast with pepper gravy, accompanied by sides such as Sweet Potato Stuffing and Bacon-Wrapped Green Beans. Dessert is a house-made Pumpkin Pie topped with crispy quinoa.
Reservations: Visit Lindens' Website to reserve your table.
Haven Rooftop
Address: 132 West 47th Street (at the Sanctuary Hotel)
Perched above the city streets, Haven Rooftop provides a festive atmosphere with panoramic views, perfect for a Thanksgiving celebration.
Thanksgiving Offering: A special prix fixe dinner at $85 per person, with seatings at 3 PM, 5 PM, 7 PM, and 9 PM. The menu includes an appetizer, entrée, and dessert, blending traditional flavors with Haven's unique culinary flair.
Reservations: Email events@sanctuaryhotelnyc.com or visit Haven Rooftop's Website for more details.
Bell Book & Candle
Address: 141 West 10th Street
Located in the West Village, Bell Book & Candle is a hidden gem known for its farm-to-table philosophy and cozy ambiance.
Thanksgiving Offering: A three-course prix fixe menu priced at $75 for adults and $45 for children. Starters include Pear & Blue Cheese Salad and Butternut Squash Soup. The main course features Lancaster Turkey with pan gravy, sourdough sage stuffing, chive mashed potatoes, and Brussels sprouts with bacon. Dessert is a Chicago Style Apple Pie with crème fraîche ice cream.
Reservations: Visit Bell Book & Candle's Website or call (212) 414-2355.
PB Brasserie
Address: 60 West 125th Street
In the heart of Harlem, PB Brasserie offers a sophisticated dining experience that marries French elegance with American holiday traditions.
Thanksgiving Offering: A special menu priced at $70, available from 11 AM to 9:30 PM. Start with pumpkin soup or Frisée au Lardon salad. Main course options include Turkey au Jus with haricot vert, mashed potatoes, and cranberry jam, or Beef Bourguignon. Desserts feature a peach tart or classic pumpkin pie with vanilla ice cream.
Reservations: Book via Resy or call (212) 280-2220.
Hole in the Wall
Locations: Murray Hill (626 1st Avenue), Williamsburg (292 Bedford Avenue), Flatiron at Hotel Henri (37 West 24th Street), FiDi (15 Cliff Street)
Known for its Australian-inspired cuisine, Hole in the Wall is celebrating Thanksgiving with special menu items across multiple locations.
Thanksgiving Offering: At Murray Hill, Williamsburg, and Flatiron locations, enjoy a Turkey Burger for $20. The FiDi location offers a 'Leftovers' Turkey Sandwich for $14. Available from November 11th through December 1st, while supplies last.
Reservations: Visit Hole in the Wall's Website to find your nearest location.
Isla & Co.
Locations: Midtown Manhattan (25 West 38th Street), Williamsburg (107 North 12th Street)
Isla & Co. brings an Australian-style all-day brasserie experience to New York, complete with coffee, cocktails, and a vibrant atmosphere.
Thanksgiving Offering: A 'Leftovers' Turkey Sandwich priced at $26, featuring confit turkey leg, potato purée, savory bread pudding, garlic butter haricot vert, cranberry chutney, and gravy. Available from November 11th through December 1st, while supplies last.
Reservations: For Midtown, reserve here. For Williamsburg, reserve here.
Angelina Bakery
Address: 575 8th Avenue (Hell's Kitchen)
Angelina Bakery is making Thanksgiving sweeter with its famous pies, available for nationwide shipping and local pickup.
Thanksgiving Offering: Pre-order Apple Pies and Pecan Pies for shipping via Goldbelly or pick up at the Hell's Kitchen location. Let Angelina Bakery handle dessert so you can focus on enjoying the holiday.
Orders: Visit Angelina Bakery's Website to place your order.
Carnegie Diner & Cafe
Locations: Near Central Park (205 West 57th Street), Times Square District (828 8th Avenue)
Offering classic American comfort food, Carnegie Diner & Cafe invites you to a hearty Thanksgiving dinner.
Thanksgiving Offering: Priced at $29.95 per person, the menu includes slow-roasted turkey marinated for over 24 hours, chestnut and pine nut stuffing, roasted Brussels sprouts, mashed sweet potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce, and cornbread rolls.
Reservations: Visit Carnegie Diner & Cafe's Website or call the respective location.
The Alderman
Address: 150A West 48th Street
The Alderman offers a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for a family-style Thanksgiving feast.
Thanksgiving Offering: A specially curated menu at $65 per person, featuring Parker House rolls, house pickles, and an array of appetizers. The main course includes roasted turkey breast with pepper gravy, sage sausage stuffing, bacon-tossed green beans, Yukon mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, and cranberry sauce with orange and rosemary. A wine and cocktail pairing is available for an additional $50 per person. Finish with a classic pumpkin pie.
Reservations: Visit The Alderman's Website to reserve your spot.
Loulou
Address: 176 8th Avenue
Located in Chelsea, Loulou is a chic French bistro and speakeasy offering a blend of classic and contemporary dishes.
Thanksgiving Offering: A prix fixe menu at $79 per person, as well as seasonal à la carte items. The menu includes butternut squash soup or jumbo lump crab cake to start, heritage roast turkey with trimmings or monkfish à la meunière for the main course, and a pumpkin layer cake for dessert. Loulou's signature dishes and extensive cocktail menu are also available.
Reservations: Visit Loulou's Website or call (212) 337-9577.
Bubby's
Locations: Tribeca (120 Hudson Street) and Terminal C at LaGuardia Airport
A New York institution since 1990, Bubby's is synonymous with comfort food and homestyle cooking. Originally opened as a Thanksgiving pie pop-up, Bubby's continues its tradition of bringing warmth and nostalgia to the holiday season.
Thanksgiving Offering:
Takeout Meal: Ready-to-eat Thanksgiving packages serving two people for $200, available for local pickup on Thanksgiving Day from 10 AM to 2 PM at the Tribeca location. The meal includes all the classics, prepared with Bubby's signature touch.
Pies for Pickup: Choose from an array of pies like pumpkin with caramel and pecan pralines, double-crust apple, Michigan sour cherry, and pecan maple, priced at $50 each. Available for pickup from November 25th–27th. Orders are open until November 21st or while supplies last.
Travelers' Delight: For those passing through LaGuardia's Terminal C, Bubby's offers comforting dishes to make your journey a bit sweeter, even amidst holiday travel chaos.
Extras: Don't forget to pick up their beloved pancake mix ($12) or browse through their selection of cookbooks and merchandise—the perfect holiday gifts supporting a local business.
Orders and Reservations: Visit Bubby's Website to place your orders or call (212) 219-0666 for the Tribeca location.
Heritage Grand Bakery, Restaurant and Pizza Bar
Address: 8 West 40th Street
An environmentally conscious eatery near Bryant Park, Heritage serves Mediterranean-inspired dishes with a focus on regenerative farming and in-house milling practices.
Thanksgiving Offering: A Turkey Entrée special and extended brunch from Friday to Sunday. The bakery offers pre-order pies including Apple Crumble Pie, Pumpkin Pie, and Pecan Pie.
Reservations and Orders: Visit Heritage's Website or call 212-419-9163..
Hortus NYC
Address: 271 5th Avenue
For those seeking to venture beyond the traditional turkey dinner, Hortus NYC offers an unconventional Thanksgiving experience with its Korean-focused menu. Located in NoMad, this modern, multi-level restaurant provides a chic ambiance that complements its innovative cuisine.
Thanksgiving Offering: A five-course special dinner menu priced at $85 per person, available from 5:00 PM to 11:00 PM on November 28th, 29th, and 30th. The meal begins with the Small Royal Platter, followed by a choice of two small plates. Entrée options include dishes such as Galbi Marinated Steak Frites, Poached Cod, or Abalone Soft Bop. Dessert features a slice of Sweet Potato Cheesecake. Guests can enhance their dining experience with an optional wine pairing for $40 per person.
Reservations: Book via Resy.
Le Tout Va Bien
Address: 311 West 51st Street
A beloved fixture in the Theater District since 1949, Le Tout Va Bien serves traditional French bistro fare infused with American classics. The restaurant exudes a warm, old-world charm, making it an ideal setting for a cozy Thanksgiving celebration.
Thanksgiving Offering: A three-course prix fixe menu priced at $75 per person, available from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM on Thanksgiving Day. Diners can choose from a variety of six appetizers, six entrées, and five desserts, allowing for a personalized dining experience. Menu highlights include classic French dishes alongside holiday favorites like Butternut Squash Soup, Roasted Turkey Ballotine, and a selection of pies including warm apple, pumpkin, and poached pear.
Reservations: Book through Resy or call (212) 265-0190.
HYUN
Address: 10 East 33rd Street
For a luxurious and intimate dining experience, HYUN offers a Michelin-recognized Japanese Wagyu beef Korean BBQ.
Thanksgiving Offering: The HYUN-makase tasting menu at $159 per person, featuring twelve hand-selected cuts of beef, marinated Wagyu, house-made sides, and optional à la carte accompaniments. A curated selection of wines, signature cocktails, sake, and soju enhance the experience.
Reservations: Visit HYUN's Website or call 917-261-6217.
This Thanksgiving, let New York City's diverse culinary landscape be the backdrop to your holiday celebrations. Whether you're craving the comfort of a traditional turkey dinner or eager to explore international flavors, there's a table set for you in the heart of the city.
Disclaimer: Please check with each restaurant for the most current information on pricing, menus, and availability. Reservations are highly recommended to ensure a seamless dining experience.
Stay updated on the latest in New York City's dining scene and real estate insights by subscribing to our newsletter and following us on social media.
